[CTC] Fwd: Political Report # 1265 What Is Behind the Renegotiation of NAFTA? Trumpism and the New Global Economy

Fri Aug 4 10:53:15 PDT 2017

Useful analysis of the current trade rhetoric versus actual policy
direction, and the role of labor exploitation and racism.

Gillian Locascio
Washington Fair Trade Coalition | 206.227.3079
www.washingtonfairtrade.org | @WaFairTrade

From: Latin American Perspectives <lap at ucr.edu>
Date: Thu, Aug 3, 2017 at 3:31 PM
Subject: Political Report # 1265 What Is Behind the Renegotiation of NAFTA?
Trumpism and the New Global Economy

[image: LAPerspectives Logo]
<http://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001HzrcGdo7A85sVsUZK9SW8QoaJ280AFqworNdALG-Cqoe31ZUH8dHChiLbvcnsjtY2sbmTq-09M0kloMrgMFl9qgULK5UNVmxoEAUPEtgNkxgLvgQgUDmm_18g-W5RmMQJ4Y6JSGPy84mvY-wVXf84reUQbdLzsBbtlVOcGhtxswXUiv9TwJchlD01D9A-Gq7&c=LByjBi8cv-JsWVfdhFil0M8ekeOCRwEfACbqwgTud5VoLMtj-VkvZw==&ch=vib-0lBOjb1ODLxaP888rBgOhp6LrbYiG3QR90DZLjI17dG6osJUSg==>

[image: Latin American Perspectives Website]
<http://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001HzrcGdo7A85sVsUZK9SW8QoaJ280AFqworNdALG-Cqoe31ZUH8dHCgjzDwv7mv98h3joc_A4og2wBmJSUkA2LRP0DZPCtRH-onSN8COwYAg2DAZsu0n9keaCd_VVa4Mo2I8mUSBGHru2_LKoCPev3hrXLfK9QQE3PNUGw2InVLiHkL1Cu-fRjtXMmlmrWOmL&c=LByjBi8cv-JsWVfdhFil0M8ekeOCRwEfACbqwgTud5VoLMtj-VkvZw==&ch=vib-0lBOjb1ODLxaP888rBgOhp6LrbYiG3QR90DZLjI17dG6osJUSg==>

Visit Our New Website!

*Featured Issue:*
<http://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001HzrcGdo7A85sVsUZK9SW8QoaJ280AFqworNdALG-Cqoe31ZUH8dHCsP_UURn9S1CGhQf8aBqI6XvDs61v3y8cfBcqmyuBTfrIOvrOlbOsD9spCyuBDyYmEhHapLG76IyRjSh8yUAVpAc9EgcH9DQsGE52KQwAtooYV3BxL9MizoYNklHQMki-SypM82oohVIlNUdvJA3ooU=&c=LByjBi8cv-JsWVfdhFil0M8ekeOCRwEfACbqwgTud5VoLMtj-VkvZw==&ch=vib-0lBOjb1ODLxaP888rBgOhp6LrbYiG3QR90DZLjI17dG6osJUSg==>
*The Chilean Earthquake of 2010: Challenging the Capabilities of the
Neoliberal State*

*Edited by: Kirsten Sehnbruch*

[image: LAPerspectives on Facebook]
<http://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001HzrcGdo7A85sVsUZK9SW8QoaJ280AFqworNdALG-Cqoe31ZUH8dHChiLbvcnsjtYh3mCIEDsA_jWKfqPKa_NmLd1qoCjTsGKKitIQbLYKTqVuow8GQh6k_edrgNRHPFtjPaYVvVXM5hwApuwQqtG_Qs--gXuZn7FOoGv7iHDIAql_TV4RNeqm2HC8D-Av2CL&c=LByjBi8cv-JsWVfdhFil0M8ekeOCRwEfACbqwgTud5VoLMtj-VkvZw==&ch=vib-0lBOjb1ODLxaP888rBgOhp6LrbYiG3QR90DZLjI17dG6osJUSg==>

Follow LAP on Facebook!

[image: LAPerspectives on Twitter]
<http://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001HzrcGdo7A85sVsUZK9SW8QoaJ280AFqworNdALG-Cqoe31ZUH8dHChiLbvcnsjtYDJOJFOcnilzmYtkn6jhVDbzBX9-Mc61hkgssYXnAH6ozn8_LIe7FXisw0bdR63-2Suqqand1FirHr8zf8T4U2ECWVevPYlNEkBIneSdAxWEfeSrzl-EsCAI6rsUmkmLk&c=LByjBi8cv-JsWVfdhFil0M8ekeOCRwEfACbqwgTud5VoLMtj-VkvZw==&ch=vib-0lBOjb1ODLxaP888rBgOhp6LrbYiG3QR90DZLjI17dG6osJUSg==>

Follow LAP on Twitter!

[image: LAPerspectives Blog]
<http://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001HzrcGdo7A85sVsUZK9SW8QoaJ280AFqworNdALG-Cqoe31ZUH8dHChiLbvcnsjtY0J85t4_OKC12Wpnq9IsDf9IoTIz6YYGUK3MbiZVow2IEJ6FcSrTTfc9s4tav5XTFeDvkgMMEQOUcHbIrhE_3r-HzZJ2iTqYz9OJzpgOCk3NlEYVmzVHCnFyxSpZTpShH&c=LByjBi8cv-JsWVfdhFil0M8ekeOCRwEfACbqwgTud5VoLMtj-VkvZw==&ch=vib-0lBOjb1ODLxaP888rBgOhp6LrbYiG3QR90DZLjI17dG6osJUSg==>

Follow LAP's Blog!

[image: LAPerspectives on Pinterest]
<http://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001HzrcGdo7A85sVsUZK9SW8QoaJ280AFqworNdALG-Cqoe31ZUH8dHChiLbvcnsjtYFTFyUU3cFwcGEMb9CNoVNer7nqmUapLkEAST9m1aIUn8rbPoUlLszm3eiYAXBgmbi_tMC0A8F91_BU0N96uoafRlY-pe8aI3TjHAQQsAO89mhFzc5HFHU6jxwlppjLwH&c=LByjBi8cv-JsWVfdhFil0M8ekeOCRwEfACbqwgTud5VoLMtj-VkvZw==&ch=vib-0lBOjb1ODLxaP888rBgOhp6LrbYiG3QR90DZLjI17dG6osJUSg==>

Follow LAP on Pinterest!

[image: LAPerspectives on LinkedIn]
<http://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001HzrcGdo7A85sVsUZK9SW8QoaJ280AFqworNdALG-Cqoe31ZUH8dHChiLbvcnsjtYkBhI6PaGFHVeGIrWmz3FjTxd-R1dP36OJwHve6b6NJiXOXLb55Rj-yBMlouzbETJkWQ4obXc3dilw2M9Z8jH7kfHuDEbeBEc2pjX848_Jw1WJ0rnrK8yiQkqbArFep6MK0AQJGgFMbM=&c=LByjBi8cv-JsWVfdhFil0M8ekeOCRwEfACbqwgTud5VoLMtj-VkvZw==&ch=vib-0lBOjb1ODLxaP888rBgOhp6LrbYiG3QR90DZLjI17dG6osJUSg==>

Follow LAP on LinkedIn!

[image: LAPerspectives on YouTube]
<http://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001HzrcGdo7A85sVsUZK9SW8QoaJ280AFqworNdALG-Cqoe31ZUH8dHChiLbvcnsjtYzyKERWh7AN3HKg4OL61DT_kqJH7uW0ZJOhU9kb7c1XlWx5-YPmpD13xyOX9wyPCgtFCka926hzeUYqOrwjSIC5nmlwk9ZpCuVRwbOmEpTFpTFifNmjJ_wnoEsZ0JfCWZ&c=LByjBi8cv-JsWVfdhFil0M8ekeOCRwEfACbqwgTud5VoLMtj-VkvZw==&ch=vib-0lBOjb1ODLxaP888rBgOhp6LrbYiG3QR90DZLjI17dG6osJUSg==>

Follow LAP on YouTube!

[image: Microphone]
<http://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001HzrcGdo7A85sVsUZK9SW8QoaJ280AFqworNdALG-Cqoe31ZUH8dHCsECr_GFtPNAuqlUKO5vaXUOLYvsJC787r0bQInU50P9B-ZQtj3PbDBWvvngkyg6lD77xgwtSYL_11AXiBAAMpN2DJts1AGg6lhBgGCDCEpqLAtg4kS037LDW_plxYBrv5v4_M4JUcbye_JduS9RxZScegPmlRB9u1G7rateC2ce&c=LByjBi8cv-JsWVfdhFil0M8ekeOCRwEfACbqwgTud5VoLMtj-VkvZw==&ch=vib-0lBOjb1ODLxaP888rBgOhp6LrbYiG3QR90DZLjI17dG6osJUSg==>

Listen to our podcasts for each LAP Issue!

[image: Latin American Perspectives Website]
<http://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001HzrcGdo7A85sVsUZK9SW8QoaJ280AFqworNdALG-Cqoe31ZUH8dHCgjzDwv7mv98h3joc_A4og2wBmJSUkA2LRP0DZPCtRH-onSN8COwYAg2DAZsu0n9keaCd_VVa4Mo2I8mUSBGHru2_LKoCPev3hrXLfK9QQE3PNUGw2InVLiHkL1Cu-fRjtXMmlmrWOmL&c=LByjBi8cv-JsWVfdhFil0M8ekeOCRwEfACbqwgTud5VoLMtj-VkvZw==&ch=vib-0lBOjb1ODLxaP888rBgOhp6LrbYiG3QR90DZLjI17dG6osJUSg==>

Visit Our New Website!

*   Political Report # 1265   *

* What Is Behind the Renegotiation of NAFTA? Trumpism and the New Global
Economy *

*   By William I. Robinson (LAP Editor), Thruthout *
The Trump administration's decision to renegotiate with Mexico the North
American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) has been interpreted by most
observers as the opening salvos of a new wave of US protectionism. But
Trump's public discourse should not be confused with the essence of his
government's economic         program and likely trade policies. A better
explanation for the renegotiation, which may begin as early as mid-August,
is to be sought in the transformation of the US and the global economy in
the years since NAFTA went into effect in 1994.

The North American economic region is part of a globally integrated
production and financial system. Even if they were so motivated, US
political and economic elites could not, without utterly disrupting and
destabilizing the country, disentangle the United States (or the North
American region) from the vast network of chains of subcontracting and
outsourcing that characterize the global economy. Trump and his billionaire
cabinet members are part of the transnational capitalist class. The Trump
family's business empire spans the globe, including factories in Mexico
that take advantage of cheap labor and export back to the United States,
thanks to the provisions of NAFTA.

Trump railed against NAFTA during his electoral campaign as part of his
strategy of garnering a base of support among sectors of the US working
class who face heightened insecurity and downward mobility as a result of
capitalist globalization. No viable candidate can hope to be elected
without putting forward a populist message. Hillary Clinton was forced as
well during the campaign to come out against the Trans-Pacific Partnership
(TPP) that Trump jettisoned upon taking office, just as Obama lashed out
against globalization and its devastating effects on working people when he
first ran for the presidency.

But beyond public discourse, there is nothing populist in the policies that
the Trump government has so far put forth. Trumponomics involves
deregulation, slashing social spending, dismantling of what remains of the
welfare state, privatization, tax breaks to corporations and the rich, and
an expansion of state subsidies to capital -- in short, neoliberalism on
steroids. The US political elite are deeply divided and mired by
infighting, but businessmen and investors are, for the most part, elated
with Trump's neoliberal program, as indicated in the steep rise of stock
prices in the months following his election.

*From the Industrial to the Digital Economy*

When NAFTA was negotiated in the early 1990s, the largest US-based
companies were automotive, appliances and machine tools, and manufacturing
still drove the US economy. At the time that NAFTA went into effect in
1994, the World Trade Organization (WTO) did not even exist, few people
used the internet, and although computers were just coming into widespread
use, there was as yet no such thing as a digital economy. The principal
objective of free trade negotiations at the time was to facilitate the
establishment of a globalized system of production by lifting restrictions
that national governments had placed on the cross-border movement of goods.
This was achieved by NAFTA, along with the creation of the World Trade
Organization in 1995. An astonishing 400 trade agreements were negotiated
around the world from 1995 to 2016.

But since NAFTA and the WTO went into effect, the global economy has
continued to experience development and transformation. In particular, the
transnationalization of services and the rise of the so-called digital/data
economy -- including communications, informatics, digital and platform
technology, e-commerce, financial services, professional and technical
work, and a host of other intangible products, such as film and music, that
require intellectual property protections -- have moved to the center of
the global capitalist agenda. In fact, worldwide growth of trade in
services has outstripped by far that of goods in the last quarter century.
By 2017, services accounted for some 70 percent of the total gross world
product.

On the one hand, the United States has led the way in the development of
the digital economy, and services account now for most growth in exports.
The United States registered a deficit of $750 billion in 2016 in trade in
goods with the rest of the world, but it ran a $250 billion surplus in
services that same year. In 2016, the United States ran a $64 billion
deficit with Mexico in trade in goods, yet according to the office of the
United States Trade Representative, it ran a nearly $7 billion services
trade surplus that year. On the other hand, Mexico is rapidly transitioning
into the digital economy. Mexican IT services surpassed $20 billion in 2016
and are expected to increase 15 percent year on year. High-tech Mexican
entrepreneurs now boast of the rise of silicon valleys in Mexico City and
Guadalajara, the country's two largest cities.

NAFTA did not include provisions related to this digital trade. In
addition, it did not include state-owned enterprises and the Mexican energy
sector, nor did it oblige Mexico to revise its labor code or abandon a
number of regulatory practices. Although the Mexican government of
President Enrique Peña Nieto has, for         the first time since the
country nationalized oil in 1938, allowed foreign energy companies to
participate in exploration and production, the energy sector still remains
(for the most part) national and owned by the state. And successive
neoliberal governments in Mexico have made limited headway in their efforts
to revise the labor code and lift regulations on the hiring and firing of
workers in order to make labor more easily exploitable.

US trade representative Robert Lighthizer, who will represent the United
States in the NAFTA renegotiation, was explicit in declaring that the
purpose of the renegotiation is to "modernize" and "update" the agreement.
"NAFTA was negotiated 25 years ago," he said, "and while our economy and
businesses have changed considerably over that period, NAFTA has not." In
particular, he said "digital trade" had barely begun when the agreement
took effect. New provisions were needed to address this digital trade, as
well as intellectual property rights, regulatory practices, state-owned
enterprises and labor regulations. Far from protectionism, by renegotiating
NAFTA and other aspects of the global trade regime, the United States is
acting to break down national barriers to service and digital trade that is
now at the cutting-edge of the global economy; that is, it is promoting the
next generation of globalization.

*Why the Nationalist, Populist and Protectionist Rhetoric?*

Attempting to explain trade, economics and international relations from an
outdated nation-state framework of analysis does more to obscure than to
elucidate the dynamics of the new global capitalism. While it is true that,
putting aside trade in services, the United States has an enormous trade
deficit with Mexico (as well as with China and many other countries), the
fact is that exports that go from Mexican to US territory are not "Mexican"
exports. They are the exports by hundreds of transnational corporations
from the United States and from all over the world, that operate in Mexican
territory and that move their products through the vast networks of the
global economy. The imports of goods into the United States from Mexico are
transnational corporate exports moving from one national territory to
another. National trade statistics conceal the transnational essence of the
new global economy, and with it, the transnational class relations behind
much contemporary international political dynamics.

So why has Trump railed out against Mexico through a discourse that is
nationalist, populist and protectionist, not to mention deeply racist? To
answer this, we need to identify a fundamental contradiction in global
capitalism: Economic globalization takes place within a system of political
authority based in the nation-state. This contradiction generates a host of
dilemmas for states and the transnational elite. Governments gain some of
their legitimacy by achieving growth, generating employment and prosperity.
Yet, in the age of capitalist globalization, governments are dependent on
attracting transnational corporate investment to the national territory,
which requires providing capital with all the incentives associated with
neoliberalism -- downward pressure on wages, deregulation, austerity, and
on so -- that aggravate inequality, impoverishment and insecurity for the
working classes.

To say this in academic terms, nation-states face a contradiction between
the need to promote transnational capital accumulation in their territories
and the need to achieve political legitimacy. Governments around the world
have been experiencing spiraling crises of legitimacy in the face of the
unprecedented inequalities and hardships imposed on the working classes by
globalization. This situation generates bewildering and seemingly
contradictory politics.

Trumpism is a far-right response to the crisis of legitimacy that rests on
a populist and nationalist message aimed in particular at those sectors of
the US working class that face increasingly precarious work and social
conditions. Trump's imperial bravado and racist discourse, in part
predicated on whipping up anti-Mexican and anti-immigrant sentiment, is an
appeal to these sectors to channel their fear and insecurity towards a
racist consciousness of their condition.

At the same time, therefore, Trump's Mexico agenda cannot be separated from
its escalation of the war against immigrants, particularly from Mexico and
Central America, inside the United States. The criminalization of
immigrants, a sharp increase in raids and detentions and "build the wall"
rhetoric are part of a larger strategy to disarticulate the political
organization and resistance that has taken place among immigrant
communities in recent years. It is not surprising that the recent wave of
detentions and deportation of immigrants from Mexico and Central America
have targeted labor and community activists among the undocumented
immigrant community.

But the US economy and the transnational capitalist class depend on the
exploitation of an immigrant workforce that is held in labor peonage due to
its lack of citizenship rights. US rulers have been exploring ways to
replace the current system of super-exploitation of undocumented immigrant
labor with a mass "guest worker program" that would be more efficient in
combining super-exploitation with super control. Indeed, while the
detention and deportation of undocumented immigrant workers in California
has escalated in recent years, the use of "guest workers" in that state's
$47 billion agricultural industry increased by 500 percent from 2011 to
2017.

All of this is not to say that Trump's populist, nationalist and
protectionist discourse should be taken lightly. This discourse is tinged
with a vicious racism, has inspired a neo-fascist mobilization of extreme
right groups in US civil society and has escalated international tensions.
But we would do better to see Trumpism as a highly contradictory and
unstable far-right response to the crisis of global capitalism than a
trenchant policy of protectionism and populism.

Original article can be found here
<http://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001HzrcGdo7A85sVsUZK9SW8QoaJ280AFqworNdALG-Cqoe31ZUH8dHCpODl8A3Va1wZf49tEjSt5C2ESinosG6YOKEW8kyAvWFfK9M-TqiXn_E3Q9_7RhSDg9cufWfijNgNRcpk31shdGvxbLgFt03bO6oVKVxZW68j7pwIVZZbKRQZhAdRuoHrMC_ak6YduILlKwfoTLt1D8Qzmw72hayh76JqZ58sXp5blJxNj9x33VUSuX2V5npfhnPEO9zAuOimCwD6QjK1fkEOq2r0s4RbNAF1MBhnt6V5xdCfOSKrO2Nn4tMAlxy0Q==&c=LByjBi8cv-JsWVfdhFil0M8ekeOCRwEfACbqwgTud5VoLMtj-VkvZw==&ch=vib-0lBOjb1ODLxaP888rBgOhp6LrbYiG3QR90DZLjI17dG6osJUSg==>
:
http://www.truth-out.org/news/item/41365-what-is-behind-the-
renegotiation-of-nafta-trumpism-and-the-new-global-economy
Latin American Perspectives, PO Box 5703, Riverside, CA 92517
SafeUnsubscribe™ levyjd at plu.edu
<https://visitor.constantcontact.com/do?p=un&m=001KWmi_zQpKodwJ1lkqJIu1Q%3D%3D&ch=f5036d60-5e61-11e6-a4fe-d4ae52844372&ca=2279b695-1d04-4ff0-a96a-a585ae586182>
Forward email
<http://ui.constantcontact.com/sa/fwtf.jsp?llr=wsjlvidab&m=1103023679062&ea=levyjd%40plu.edu&a=1128532562154>
 | Update Profile
<https://visitor.constantcontact.com/do?p=oo&m=001KWmi_zQpKodwJ1lkqJIu1Q%3D%3D&ch=f5036d60-5e61-11e6-a4fe-d4ae52844372&ca=2279b695-1d04-4ff0-a96a-a585ae586182>
 | About our service provider
<http://www.constantcontact.com/legal/service-provider?cc=about-service-provider>
Sent by lap at ucr.edu in collaboration with
[image: Constant Contact]
<http://www.constantcontact.com/index.jsp?cc=TEM_News_203>
Try it free today <http://www.constantcontact.com/index.jsp?cc=TEM_News_203>

-- 
Jordan Levy, PhD
Assistant Professor of Anthropology
Pacific Lutheran University
Tacoma, Washington, USA
Phone: 253/535-8285 <253%2F535-7297>   Office: Xavier 110
email: levyjd at plu.edu <ceynarml at plu.edu>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.citizenstrade.org/pipermail/ctcfield-citizenstrade.org/attachments/20170804/c6dde456/attachment-0001.htm>